The Comparison of Olson's Circumplex Model and the Beavers' Systems Model in terms of the Relationship between Family Adaptability and Family Function

가족 적응력과 가족기능과의 관계 : Olson의 순환모델의 곡선성과 Beavers의 체계모 델의 선형성

  • 장진경 (숙명여자대학교 가정관리학과)
  • Published : 1995.12.01

Abstract

Various theoretical models have developed io both a family research area and family therapy field on he basis of several family theories and social theories in order to understand the family life and its function. These theoretical models have give rise to provide not only a framework for family therapy bt also opportunities for the development of family studies. Regardless of the devotion of these theoretical models to a family therapy however some family therapy professions have suggested the disvergence between these models and practice because the models tend to confuse therapists in their actual practices Other family therapists on the other hand have claimed the convergence between these models and practice. One of the reasons for the issues of convergence and disvergence in the family therapy study would be that various theoretical models have different sometimes contradicatable definitions and explanations for same concept. Therefore the purpose of this paper is to investigate the extent of similarities and differences among these theoretical models of practice in a way of examining family models to compare Olson's circumplex model to the Beavers systems model. Both models were based on the general systems theory. This paper consists of the explanation of Olson's circumplex model and Beavers systems model in general respectively. Then it will investigate similarities and differences between these two models in terms of the relationship between family functioning and family adaptability.

Keywords

References

  1. 한국가정관리학회지 v.11 부부의 응집 및 적응과 의사소통의 관계: 순환모델의 곡선성 대선형성 김수윤;김득성
  2. 서울대학교 대학원 석사학위논문 청소년 비행정도와 부모-자녀간 의사소통 가족의 응집 및 적응과의 관계 민하영
  3. 연세대학교 대학원 석사학위논문 Circumplex Model에 입각한 한국의 임상가족과 일반가족의 비교연구 유순덕
  4. 가족학 한국가족학연구회
  5. No single thread:Psychological health in family systems A thoretical basis for family evaluation Beavers,W.R.;J.M.Lewis(eds.);W.R.Beavers(eds.),J.T.Gossett(eds.);V.A.Phillips(eds.)
  6. Family Process v.24 Commentary: The Beavers systems approach to family assessment Beavers,W.R.;Hampson,R.B.;Hulgus,Y.F.
  7. Family Process v.22 Epilogue Beavers,W.R.;Olson,D.H.
  8. Family Process v.22 Family models: Comparing and contrasting the Olson circumplex model wkth the Beavers systems model Beavers,W.R.;Voeller,M.N.
  9. American Journal of Family Therapy v.14 Review: Beavers-Timberlawn family evaluation scale Brock,G.W.
  10. The Journal fo Marriage and the Family Self-esteem and family cohesion: The child's perspective and adjustment Cooper,J.E.;Holman,J.;Braithwaite,V.A.
  11. Childhood and Society(2d ed.) Erikson,E.
  12. Counseling Today's Families Goldenberg,H.;Godenberg,I.
  13. Family Process v.24 The Beavers-Timberlawn model of family competence and the circumplex model of family adaptability and cohesion: Separte, but equal? Green,R.G.;Kolevzon,M.S.;Vosler,N.R.
  14. Family Process v.27 Commentary: Comparing the Beavers and circumplex model of family functioning Hampson,R.B.;Beavers,W.R.;Hulgus,Y.F.
  15. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy v.11 The McMaster family assessment device: Reliability and validity Miller,I.W.;Epatein,N.B.;Bishop,D.S.;Keitner,G.I.
  16. Families and family therapy Minuchin,S.
  17. Family Process v.22 Circumplex model of marital and family systems: Ⅵ. Theoretical update Olsen,D.H.;Russell,C.;Sprenkle,D.H.
  18. Family Process v.18 Circumplex model of marital and family systems: Ⅰ. Cohesion and adaptability dimenstions, family types, and clinical applications Olsen,D.H.;Sprenkle,D.H.;Russell,C.
  19. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology v.14 An evaluation of family adaptability and cohesion scales and the circumplex model Rodick,J.D.;Henggeler,S.W.;Hanson,C.L.
  20. Family Process v.18 Circumplex model of marital and family systems Ⅲ: Empirical evaluation with families Russell,C.S.
  21. Family Process v.9 Family systems: Morphostasis and morphogenesis, or Is homeostasis enough? Speer,D.C.
  22. Annals American Society Adolescence Psychiatry v.2 Centrifugal versus centripetal separation in Adolescence: Two patterns and some of their implications Stierlin,H.;Levi,L.;Savard,R.;S.Feinstein(eds.);P.Giovacchini(eds.)
  23. Psychiatry v.21 Pseudo-mutuality in the family relations of schizophrenics Wynne,L.C.;Ryckoff,I.M.;Day,J.;Hirsch,S.I.