Effects of Morphine and Buprenorphine Intravenous Infusion for Postoperative Pain

Morphine과 Buprenorphine의 지속적 정주에 의한 술후 통증 억제효과의 비교

Morphine, a $\mu$-receptor agonist, produces strong analgesic effect with some side effects such as nausea, vomiting, urinary retension, somnolence, and respiratory depression. Buprenorphine also provides strong analgesic effects, and hemodynamic changes after continuous infusion of morphine, or buprenorphine-ketorolac combination in gynecologic patients. Analgesic effect was assessed by visual analogue scale(VAS) and Prince Henry scale(PHS). Morphine group, initial 2 mg of bolus morphine was followed by 48 mg/96 ml of continuous infusion. Buprenorphine group, initial 0.1 mg of buprenorphine was followed up with infusion by 2.3 mg/100 ml. Half dose of both initial bolus and maintenance buprenorphine with ketorolac 15 mg for bolus and 60 mg for maintenance were infused in buprenorphine-ketorolac combination group. No significant hemodynamic changes were seen in any of the groups. VAS significantly decreased after 15 minutes of infusion in all three groups, and was significantly lower in morphine group than the other 2 groups, after 60 minutes. PHS was decreased significantly 15 minutes after infusion in the morphine group, and after 60 minutes in two other groups. The incidence of side effects were similar between morphine and buprenorphine groups, but significantly reduced in buprenorphine-ketorolac combination group. We concluded that buprenorphine could be an alternative to morphine for postoperative pain, and smaller dose of buprenorphine could be used if it is combined with ketorolac with less side effects.

수술후 통증치료에 morphine과 buprenorphine의 효과를 알아보기 위하여 morphine과 buprenorphinec을 단독 투여하거나(1, 2군) buprenorphine과 ketorolac을 반량씩 혼합하여 지속적으로 정주(3군)하여 다음과 같은 결과를 얻었다. 1) 각군에서 모두 혈압과 맥박의 의의있는 변화는 초래하지 않았다. 2) Visual analogue scale으로 평가한 진통 발현은 각군에서 모두 비슷하였다. 3) Visual analogue scale과 Prince Henry Scale로 평가한 진통효과는 morphine군에서 가장 우수하였고, buprenorphine군과 buprenorphine+ketorolac의 반량 투여군에서는 비슷하였다. 4) 부작용의 발생은 1군과 2군에서 비슷하였으나 3군에서 가장 낮았다. 이상의 결과로 보아 지속적 정주에 의한 술후 통증의 억제에 있어서 buprenorphine은 morphine을 대치할 수는 있으나 morphine보다 우수하지는 못한 것으로 사료되며, buprenorphine 사용시는 ketorolac을 병용하여 사용량을 줄염으로써 부작용을 줄일 수 있을 것으로 사료된다.