Low Grade Astrocytoma-Need Postoperative Radiotherapy or Not?

저분화 성상세포종-수술후 방사선치료가 필수적인가 ?

  • Hong Seong Eon (Department of Therapeutic Radiology, Kyung Hee University School of Medicine) ;
  • Choi Doo Ho (Department of Therapeutic Radiology, Kyung Hee University School of Medicine) ;
  • Kim Tee Sung (Department of Neurosurgery, Kyung Hee University School of Medicine) ;
  • Leem Won (Department of Neurosurgery, Kyung Hee University School of Medicine)
  • 홍성언 (경희대학교 의과대학 치료방사선과학교실) ;
  • 최두호 (경희대학교 의과대학 치료방사선과학교실) ;
  • 김태성 (경희대학교 의과대학 신경외과학교실) ;
  • 임언 (경희대학교 의과대학 신경외과학교실)
  • Published : 1992.12.01

Abstract

The precise role of radiotherapy for low grade gliomas including the optimal radiation dose and timing of treatment remains unclear. The information given by a retrosepctive analysis may be useful in the design of prospective randomized studies looking at radiation dose and time of surgical and radiotherapeutic treatment. The records of 56 patients (M:F = 29:27) with histologically verified cerebral low grade gliomas (47 cases of grade 1 or 2 astrocytomas and 9 oligodendrogliomas) diagnosed between 1979 and 1989 were retrospectively reviewed. The extent of surgical tumor removal was gross total or radical subtotal in 38 patients ($68\%$) and partial or biopsy only in the remaining 18 patients ($32\%$). Postooperative radiation therapy was given to 36 patients ($64\%$) of the total 56 patients with minimum dose of 5000 cGy (range=1250 to 7220 cGy). The 5-and 10-year survival rates for the total 56 patients were $44\%$ and $32\%$ respectively with a median survival of 4.1 years. According to the histologic grade the 5- and 10-year survivals were $52\%$ and $35\%$ for the 24 patients respectively with grade I astrocytomas compared to $20\%$ and $10\%$ for the 23 patients with grade II astrocytomas. Survival of oligodendroglioma patients was greater than those with astrocytoma ($65\%$ vs $36\%$ at 5 years), and the difference was also remarkable in the long term period of follow up ($54\%$ vs $23\%$ at 10 years). Those who received high-dose radiation therapy ($\geq$5400 cGy) had significant better survival than those who received low-dose radiation (< 5400cGy) or surgery alone (p<0.05). The 5- and 10-year survival rates were, respectively $59\%$ and $46\%$ for the 23 patients receiving high-dose radiation, $36\%$ and $24\%$ for the 13 patients receiving low-dose radiation, and $35\%$ and $26\%$ for the 20 patients with surgery alone. Survival rates by the extent of surgical resection were similar at 5 years ($46\%$ vs $41\%$), but long term survival was quite different (p<0.01) between total/subtotal resection and partial resection/biopsy ($41\%$ and $12\%$, resepctively). Previously published studies have identified important prognostic factors in these tumor: age, extent of surgery, grade, performance status, and duration of symptoms. But in our cases statistical analysis revealed that grade I histology (p<0.025) and young age (p<0.001) were the most significant good prognostic variables.

저분화 성상세포종에 대한 방사선 치료의 역할이나 적정 방사선량, 치료시기등은 논란의 여지가 많다. 후향적 분석결과로 얻은 정보는 방사선량이나 외과적 또는 방사선 치료에 의한 시술시기 등의 관점에서 전향적인 연구계획을 세우는데 도움이 된다. 저자들은 1979년부터 1989년까지 경희대학병원에서 수술로 확진된 저분화 성상세포종 환자중 천막하부를 제외한 총 56(남 : 여 =29:27)명에 대한 치료결과를 후향적으로 분석하였다. 수술절제범위는 38명 ($68\%$)에서 근치수술하였고, 18예 ($32\%$)는 부분절제 또는 조직생검만 시행하였다. 총 56예중 수술후 방사선치료를 받은 환자는 36명 ($64\%$)이었고, 방사선량은 최저 5000 cGy를 국소조사하였다. 총 56예의 5년 및 10년 생존율은 각각 $44\%$$32\%$였으며, 중간 생존기간은 4.1년이었다. 조직소견에 따른 5년 및 10년 생존율은 grade I(23명)이 각각 $52\%$$35\%$이고, grade II(23명)는 $20\%$$10\%$였다. Oligodendroglioma 환자는 성상세포종보다 생존율이 높았으며(5년 생존율=$65\%$ vs $36\%$)장기간 생존율은 각각 $54\%$$23\%$로 현저한 차이가 있었다. 다량의 방사선치료를 받은 (<54 Gy)환자는 소량의 방사선 (<54 Gy)이나 수술만 받은 환자보다 5-년 및 10-년 생존율이 높았다(P<0.05). 수술범위에 따른 5년 생존율은 $46\%$$41\%$로 비슷하였으나, 10년 생존율은 근치수술한 경우가 $41\%$, 부분절제 또는 조직생검한 경우는 $12\%$로 현저한 차이가 있었다(p<0.01). 과거 여러 저자들의 연구에 의하면 환자나이, 수술범위, 방사선치료유무, 악성도, 증상 발현기간, 수행능력 상태등이 성상세포종의 중요 예후인자라고보고하였으나, 본 저자들의 예에서는 grade I조직소견 (p<0.025)과 환자나이 (p<0.001)가 가장 중요한 예후일자였으며 향후 무작위화한 전향적인 연구가 필요할 것으로 생각된다.

Keywords