- Volume 16 Issue 3
DOI QR Code
A Case Study on Running the Permanent Judge System of the Korean Sport & Olympic Committee
대한체육회 상임심판제도 운영실태에 관한 사례연구
- Kim, Mi-Suk (Korea Institute of Sport Science) ;
- Kim, Il-Gwang (Korea National Sport University) ;
- Jeon, Sang-Wan (GaChon University)
- Received : 2017.12.18
- Accepted : 2018.03.20
- Published : 2018.03.28
The purpose of this study is to diagnose problems of the permanent judge system by examining the cases of practical running of the permanent judge system, and to provide basic materials for the settlement of fair and transparent judge culture. The findings of the case studies are as follows. First, the difficulties in selection, allocation, and education of judges caused by the operation of the permanent judge system. The problems in allocation are forceful allocation, conflict over allocation with general judges. The problems in evaluation are individual evaluation and limits of fairness, lack of evaluation rules. Second, the unpredictability of whether the permanent judge system survive or not. Third, there are some environmental constraints of the permanent judge system. Lack of protective apparatus is lack of rescue method and solution for intentional protest. Forth, there is a problem of low recognition of the permanent judge system. As the federation has been not active in publicizing the permanent judge system, the system is not well known.
KSOC;Permanent judge system;Operational practices;Qualitative case study;Permanent judge;improvement
- Korea institute of sport science. (2016). Permanent Judge System Operation Evaluation Research.
- KBS, Father suicide... Details a Taekwondo match fixing?. http://news.kbs.co.kr
- Korea institute of sport science. (2015). Permanent Judge System Operation Evaluation Research.
- E. A. Hong & C. H. Hahm. (2013). A Study Investigating the Experiences of the Korean Female Soccer Referees for Establishing Referee Related Policies. Journal of Korean Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women, 27(2), 65-78.
- K. H. Seo. (2014). The Fairness of the Referees for Recovery Rationale and Practice. Journal of Korean Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women, 28(3), 61-70.
- H. Kim, S. J. Choi & J. H. Kim. (2016). Sports Referees' Biased Judgment and Improvement. Korean Journal of Sports Science, 25(5), 105-116.
- D. H. Kim. (2015). A grounded theory approach toward the nonnalization process in amateur sports referee. The Korean Journal of Physical Education, 54(3), 253-264.
- Y. H. Chang & J. K. Park. (2016). Qualitative Study on Operating States and Improvement Strategies of Korean Soccer Referee System. Journal of Coaching Development, 18(2), 55-65.
- Y. Pang. (2004). Officiating in Korean Professional Basketball -Major Problems and Some Solutions Thereto. Korean Journal of Sport Pedagogy, 11(2), 159-175.
- K. H. Aum & T. S. Yun. (1991). A Study on the Actual Condition and Perception of Boxing Referees. The Korean Journal of Physical Education, 30(1), 1397-1415.
- Korea institute of sport science. (2014). Permanent Judge System Operation Evaluation Research.
- Creswell. J. W.(2007). Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design. 2E. CA: Sage Publications.
- McNabb, D. E. (2002). Research methods in public Administration and Nonprofut management : Qualitative and Quautitative Approaches. Armonk. NY: N. E. Sharpe.
- Clandinin, D. J. & Connelly, F. M. (2000). Narrative inquiry : Experience and story in Qualitative Research. San Francisco: Jossey Bass Publishers.
- Levitt, H, Bulter, M. & T. Hill. (2006). What clients find helpful in psychotherapy : Developing principles for facilitating moment-to-moment change. Journal of Counseling Psycology, 53, 314-324. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0220.127.116.114