Analysis of Citations in Undergraduate Papers

대학생 과제보고서에 나타난 인용정보 분석에 관한 연구

  • 박성재 (한성대학교 지식정보학부)
  • Received : 2016.02.01
  • Accepted : 2016.02.18
  • Published : 2016.02.29


The purpose of this study is to gain a better understanding of undergraduate citation behavior and to measure the contribution which an academic library makes in the academic writing of students. Citations in 80 student papers submitted in the academic paper competition was analyzed for types of items cited and the number of items in the library collection, etc. The findings indicate: 1) the level of undergraduates' citation knowledge is very low, 2) undergraduates prefer web resources (44.9%) to such academic resources as books, journal articles, theses or dissertation, and 3) undergraduates find academic resources in their academic library. Upon these findings, this study suggests that academic library staff should intervene to enhance undergraduate academic writing skills and to develope of educational material, including how to search for and cite reliable resources.


Undergraduate;Citation;Reference;Research Ethics;Academic Library;Literacy Education;Outcome


Supported by : 한성대학교


  1. 곽동철. 2007. 학술논문에서 표절의 유형과 올바른 인용 방식에 관한 고찰. 한국문헌정보학회지, 41(3): 103-126.(Kwack, Dong-Chul. 2007. "A Study on the Types of Plagiarism and Appropriate CitationPractices of Writing Research Papers." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and InformationScience, 41(3): 103-126.)
  2. 김성수. 2008. 미국 대학의 '학문적 정직성' 정책에 대한 연구- 대학 글쓰기에서 '표절' 문제를 중심으로. 작문연구, 6: 193-226.(Kim, Sungsoo. 2008. "A Study on the 'Academic Honesty' Policy in the U.S. Universities:Focusing on the Problem of 'Plagiarism' in College Writing." Research on Writing, 6: 193-226.)
  3. 송영희 외. 2013. 디지털시대의 장서관리. 서울: 한국도서관협회.(Song, Young-Hee. 2013. Collection Management in the Digital Era. Seoul: Korean LibraryAssociation.)
  4. 심원식, 변제연, 김민정. 2013. 학술논문에서의 위키피디아 인용에 관한 연구. 한국문헌정보학회지, 47(2): 247-264.(Shim, Wonski, Byun, Jeayeon and Kim, Minjung. 2013. "Analysis of Wikipedia Citations inPeer-Reviewed Journal Articles." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and InformationScience, 47(2): 247-264.)
  5. 이인영. 2011. 대학생의 학술적 글쓰기에 나타난 자료 이용 실태 분석. 비평문학, 41: 279-320.(Lee, In-Young. 2011. "Analysis of the Condition of Use of Data at Academic Writing ofCollege Student." Literary Criticism, 41: 279-320.)
  6. 이지연, 이상곤. 2008. 과제표절과 관련한 대학생의 디지털 정보원 활용 현황에 관한 조사연구. 열린교육연구, 16(3): 103-121.(Lee, Ji-Yeon and Lee, Sang-Kon. 2008. "A Study on the College Students' Misuse of DigitalInformation Resources." The Journal of Yeolin Education, 16(3): 103-121.)
  7. 이혜영, 남태우. 2010. 대학생들의 인용 및 표절에 관한 인식연구. 한국문헌정보학회지, 44(3): 175-198.(Rhee, Hey-Young and Nam, Tae-Woo. 2010. "A Study on Undergraduates' Citation Useand Plagiarism Awareness." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science,44(3): 175-198.)
  8. 이혜영. 2011. 대학도서관에서의 과제 작성 교육에 관한 연구. 한국도서관.정보학회지, 42(1): 369-395.(Rhee, Hey-Young. 2011. "A Study on Paper Writing Education in Academic Library." Journalof Korean Library and Information Science Society, 42(1): 369-395.)
  9. 이혜영. 2012. 대학도서관의 인용 및 참고문헌작성 교육 현황. 한국비블리아학회지, 23(3): 35-56.(Rhee, Hey-Young. 2012. "The Present Condition on Education of Citation & Reference Writingin Academic Library." Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science,23(3): 35-56.)
  10. 최선경. 2009. 대학생 글쓰기에 나타난 오류 분석: 인용방식의 오류를 중심으로. 새국어교육, 81: 299-324.(Choi, Seon Kyung. 2009. "Analysis of Errors in Academic Writing of University Students:Focusing on the Style of Citation." Korean Education, 81: 299-324.)
  11. Ackerson, L. G. and Young, V. E. 1994. "Evaluating the Impact of Library Instruction Methods on the Quality of Student Research." Research Strategies, 12(3): 132-144.
  12. Anthony, D., Smith, S. W. and Williamson, T. 2009. "Reputation and Reliability in Collective Goods the Case of the Online Encyclopedia Wikipedia." Rationality and Society, 21(3): 283-306.
  13. Barnard, E. and Weaver, N. E. 2011. Student Use of Sources: A Collaborative Investigation of Resource Use in Tertiary-level Psychology Assignments. Lower Hutt: The Open Poytechnic. [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  14. Brown, A. R. 2011. "Wikipedia as a Data Source for Political Scientists: Accuracy and Completeness of Coverage." PS: Political Science & Politics, 44(2): 339-343.
  15. Carlin, J. A. and Damschroder, C. B. 2009. "Beautiful and Useful: The Book as a Learning Object." College & Research Library News, 70(3): 168-183.
  16. Carlson, J. 2006. "An Examination of Undergraduate Student Citation Behavior." Journal of Academic Librarianship, 32(1): 14-22.
  17. Cooke, R. and Rosenthal, D. 2011. "Students Use More Books after Library Instruction: An Analysis of Undergraduate Paper Citations." College & Research Libraries, 72(4): 332-343.
  18. Davis, P. M. 2003. "Effect of the Web on Undergraduate Citation Behavior: Guiding Student Scholarship in a Networked Age." portal: Libraries and the Academy, 3(1): 41-51.
  19. Dodgen, L. et al. 2003. "Not so SILI: Sociology Information Literacy Infusion as the Focus of Faculty and Librarian Collaboration." Community & Junior College Libraries, 11(4): 27-33.
  20. Giles, J. 2005. "Internet Encyclopaedias Go Head to Head." Nature, 438(7070): 900-901.
  21. Gratch, B. 1985. "Toward a Methodology for Evaluating Research Paper Bibliographies." Research Strategies, 3(4): 170-77.
  22. Grimes D. J. and Boening C. H. 2001. "Worries with the Web: A Look at Student Use of Web Resources." College & Research Libraries, 62(1): 11-22.
  23. Haddow, G. 2013. "Academic Library Use and Student Retention: A Quantitative Analysis." Library & Information Science Research, 35(2): 127-136.
  24. Head, A. J. and Eisenberg, M. B. 2010. "How Today's College Students Use Wikipedia for Course-Related Research." First Monday, 15(3). [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  25. Hovde, K. 2000. "Check the Citation: Library Instruction and Student Paper Bibliographies." Research Strategies, 17(1): 3-9.
  26. Hurst, S. and Leonard, J. 2007. "Garbage in, Garbage out: The Effect of Library Instruction on the Quality of Students' Term Papers." The Electronic Journal of Academic and Special Librarianship, 8(1). [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  27. Knight-Davis, S. and Sung, J. S. 2008. "Analysis of Citations in Undergraduate Papers." College & Research Libraries, 69(5): 447-458.
  28. Kohl, D. F. and Wilson, L. A. 1986. "Effectiveness of Course-Integrated Bibliographic Instruction in Improving Coursework." RQ, 1986: 206-211.
  29. Leiding, R. 2005. "Using Citations Checking of Undergraduate Honors Thesis Bibliographies to Evaluate Library Collections." College & Research Libraries, 66(5): 417-429.
  30. Magnus, P. D. 2008. "Early Response to False Claims in Wikipedia." First Monday, 13(9). [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  31. Malone, D. and Videon, C. 1997. "Assessing Undergraduate Use of Electronic Resources: A Quantitative Analysis of Works Cited." Research Strategies, 15(3): 151-158.
  32. Mesgari, M. et al. 2015. "The Sum of All Human Knowledge: A Systematic Review of Scholarly Research on the Content of Wikipedia." Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 66(2): 219-245.
  33. Mill, D. H. 2008. "Undergraduate Information Resource Choices." College & Research Libraries, 69(4): 342-355.
  34. Oakleaf, M. 2012. Value of Academic Libraries: A Comprehensive Research Review and Report. Chigago, IL: American Library Association. [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  35. Rector, L. 2008. "Comparison of Wikipedia and Other Encyclopedias for Accuracy, Breadth, and Depth in Historical Articles." Reference services review, 36(1): 7-22.
  36. Robinson, A. M. and Schlegl, K. 2004. "Student Bibliographies Improve When Professors Provide Enforceable Guidelines for Citations." portal: Libraries and the Academy, 4(2): 275-290. [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  37. Selegean, J. C., Thomas, M. L. and Richman, M. L. 1983. "Long-Range Effectiveness of Library Use Instruction." College & Research Libraries, 44(6): 476-480.
  38. Smith, E. T. 2003. "Assessing Collection Usefulness: An Investigation of Library Ownership of the Resources Graduate Students Use." College & Research Libraries, 64(5): 344-355.
  39. Sylvia, M. J. 1998. "Citation Analysis as an Unobtrusive Method for Journal Collection Evaluation Using Psychology Student Research Bibliographies." Collection Building, 17(1): 20-28.
  40. Wilson, E. K. 2012. "Citation Analysis of Undergraduate Honors Thesis." The Southeastern Librarian, 60(1): 39-50.
  41. Wang, R. 2006. "The Lasting Impact of a Library Credit Course." portal: Libraries and the Academy, 6(1): 79-92.
  42. Wong, S. H. R. and Cmor, D. 2011. "Measuring Association between Library Instruction and Graduation GPA." College & Research Libraries, 72(5): 464-473. [online] [cited 2016. 1. 31.]
  43. Yu, F., Sullivan, J. and Woodall, L. 2006. "What Can Students' Bibliographies Tell Us?: Evidence Based Information Skills Teaching for Engineering Students." Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, 1(2): 12-22.