A Study on the Agenda-Setting Process for Alternatives in Application of Fixed Book Price Policy to Libraries: Based on the Policy Network Model

도서정가제의 도서관 적용에 대한 대안 정책 의제화 과정 연구 - 정책네트워크 모형을 적용하여 -

  • 허고은 (연세대학교 문헌정보학과 대학원) ;
  • 김기영 (연세대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Received : 2015.10.22
  • Accepted : 2015.11.05
  • Published : 2015.11.30


The Fixed book price policy, a portion of publication and printing promotion act applied from February 2003 in the South Korea, is a system of fixed book prices that administered by a government body. The publishing industries had been attempted to lower the discount rate and to extend the application scope. The amendment for the attempts was passed in April 2014, and implemented from November 2014. From the library point of view, this amendment caused a reduction of buying library materials. For this reason, the agenda about expansion of material budget in libraries has been recognized as the alternative. The purpose of this study is to analyze the stance and role of libraries as actors in the policy process. Based on this, this study also attempt to identify usefulness and improvement point of Policy Network Model. For this purpose, this study identifies actor's internal characteristics as an improvement point that previous studies did not identified.


Library Information Policy;Fixed Book Price Policy;Policy Network Model


  1. 공공도서관 '도서정가제' 울상. 2014. 매일신문. 12월 5일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Gonggongdoseogwan 'Doseojeonggaje' Ulsang." 2014. Maeil. December 5. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  2. 공공도서관 3천개 되면 초판 3천부 소화. 2015. 내일신문. 1월 19일. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] ("Gonggongdoseogwan 3cheongae Doemyeon Chopan 3cheonbu Sohwa." 2015. Naeil. January 19. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] )
  3. 공공도서관 위주 '기본법' 강화. 2015. 내일신문. 4월 13일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Gonggongdoseogwan Wiju 'Gibonbeop Ganghwa." 2015. Naeil. April 13. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  4. 공공도서관 자료구입 예산 늘려야. 2014. 내일신문. 11월 17일. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] ("Gonggongdoseogwan Jaryoguip Yesan Neulryeoya." 2014. Naeil. November 17. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] )
  5. 김순양. 2003. 정책네트워크 모형의 이론적 쟁점 분석. 정부학연구, 9(1): 178-217.(Kim, Soon Yang. 2003. "Theoretical Debates on the Policy Networks Model in Policy Science." Governmental Study, 9(1): 178-217.)
  6. 김순양. 2007. 정책과정 및 정책 네트워크의 동태성 분석: 의약분업 논쟁사례의 적용. 지방정부연구, 11(3): 243-269.(Kim, Soon Yang. 2007. "The Dynamics of Policy Making and Policy Networks: Case Study on the Separation of Dispensary from Medical Practice." The Korean Journal of Local Government Studies, 11(3): 243-269.)
  7. 김영종. 2009. 고용정책형성과정의 동태성 분석. 한국정책과학학회보, 13(2): 119-144.(Kim, Young Jong. 2009. "An Analysis on the Dynamics of Policy Making Process for Employment Policy." The Korean Journal of Policy Science, 13(2): 119-144.)
  8. 김예승, 홍성우. 2010. 정책네트워크를 통한 비선호시설 입지갈등 분석: 원지동 '서울추모공원' 사례를 중심으로. 한국정책연구, 10(2): 29-49.(Kim, Ye Seung and Hong, Sung Woo. 2010. "A Policy Network Analysis on Locational Conflict of Antipathy Facility: Focusing on 'Seoul Memorial Park.'" Journal of Korean Policy Studies, 10(2): 29-49.)
  9. 김옥일. 2008. 정책네트워크 변화와 정책변동에 관한 연구: 교육행정정보시스템(NEIS) 사업을 중심으로. 한국정책학회, 17(2): 207-234.(Kim, Ok Il. 2008. "A Study on the Change of Policy Network and Policy Change: Focusing on the Project of the National Education Information System (NEIS)" Journal of Policy Studies, 17(2): 207-234.)
  10. 김유승. 2008. 복합적 웹 아카이빙 정책에 관한 고찰. 한국문헌정보학회지, 42(4): 159-179.(Kim, You-Seung. 2008. "A Study of Combined Web Archiving Policy: BuF's Three Layers Web Archiving Strategy." Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science, 42(4): 159-179.)
  11. 김종철. 2015a. 대학도서관의 당면과제와 현안 세미나. 서울: 한국대학도서관연합회.(Kim, Jong Chul. 2015a. Daehakdoseokwanui Dangmyeongwajewa Hyeonan Semina. Seoul: The Korea University & College Library Association.)
  12. 김종철. 2015b. 한국대학도서관연합회 사무총장 김종철 면담, 2015년 5월 14일.(Kim, Jong Chul. 2015b. "Hangukdaehakdoseokwanyeonhaphoe Samuchongjang Kimjongchul Myeondam, May 14, 2015.")
  13. 대한민국 국회. 법률지식정보시스템. 서울: 대한민국 국회. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] (The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea. Bupryulgisikjeongbosiseutem. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] )
  14. 대한민국 국회. 의안정보시스템. 서울: 대한민국 국회. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] (The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea. Uianjeongbosiseutem. Seoul: The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] )
  15. 도서정가제 개정 13일째, 서민 위한 도서관은 울상. 2014. 아시아뉴스통신. 12월 3일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Doseojeonggaje gaejeong 13iljjae, Seomin Wihan Doseogwaneun Ulsang." Asia News Agency. December 3. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  16. 도서정가제 시행 ... 대학가도 비상. 2014. 한국대학신문. 11월 24일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Doseojeonggaje Sihange … Daehakgado Bisang." 2014. Daily UNN. November 24. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.]
  17. 도서정가제 시행 ... 도서관 예산 늘려야. 2014. 내일신문. 12월 29일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Doseojeonggaje Sihang … Doseogwan Yesan Neulryeoya." 2014. Naeil. December 29. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  18. 도서정가제 시행 두 달 ... 대학도서관은 위기. 2015. 한국대학신문. 1월 6일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Doseojeonggaje Sihange Du Dal DaehakDoseogwanun Wigi." 2015. Daily UNN. January 6. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  19. 도서정가제 18개월 지나면 다시 책정한다. 2014. 경향신문. 1월 26일. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] ("Doseojeonggaje 18gaewol Jinameon Dasi Chaekjeonghanda." 2014. The Kyunghyang Shinmun. January 26. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] )
  20. 도종환 외. 2015. 도서관법 전부개정법률안. 의안번호 1914519.(Do, Jong Hwan et al. 2015. Doseogwanbeop Jeonbugaejeongbeopryulan. No. 1914519.)
  21. '독자 발굴' 위해 협력해야 출판 생태계 성장한다. 2015. 내일신문. 1월 26일. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] ("'Dokja Balgul' Wihae Hyeopryeokhaeya Chulpan Saengtaegye Seongjanghanda." 2015. Naeil. January 26. [online] [cited 2015. 5. 18.] )
  22. 문체부, '새 도서정가제' 보완키로 출판․유통계와 합의. 2014. 뉴스1. 10월 21일. [online] [cited 2015. 4. 29.] ("Munchebu, 'Sae Doseojeonggaje' Bowankiro Chulpan․yutonggye hapui." 2014. New1. October 21. [online] [cited 2015. 4. 29.] )
  23. 문화체육관광부, 법률 제13308호, 출판문화산업 진흥법. (일부개정 2015. 5. 18)(Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, No. 13308, Chulpanmunhwasaup Jinheungbup. (Partially Amended May 18, 2015))
  24. 박상원, 김재영, 2006. 정책네트워크 모형을 통한 방통융합기구 논의 분석: 행위자, 구조 및 상호작용을 중심으로. 사회과학연구, 17: 99-112.(Park, Sangwon and Kim, Jae Young. 2006. "Analysis of the Discussions on the Issue of the Establishment of Single Broadcasting-Telecommunications System by a Policy-Network Model." Journal of Social Science, 17: 99-112.)
  25. 박상원, 박치성. 2009. IPTV 정책과정에 관한 분석. 한국행정학보, 43(3): 197-228.(Park, Sangwon and Park, Chi Sung. 2009. "The Case Study on IPTV Policy Processes: Focusing on Changes in Belief Systems of Advocacy Coalitions." Korean Public Administration Review, 43(3): 197-228.)
  26. 방민석. 2003. 전자정부 구축과정의 정책네트워크 분석: 정책패러다임의 변동을 중심으로. 박사 학위논문, 성균관대학교 행정대학원.(Bang, MinSeok. 2003. An Analysis of the Policy Networks in the Process of E-Government Construction in Korea: Focusing on the Policy Paradigm Shift. Ph.D. diss., Sungkyunkwan University.)
  27. 법무법인 선우. 2014. 출판문화산업진흥법 개정에 따른 법률해석의건, 2014년 9월 19일.(Sunwoo. 2014. "Chulpanmunhwasanupjinheungbup Garjeonge ttareun Beopryulhaeseokui Geon, September 19, 2014.")
  28. 법안심사소위원회. 2014. 제 323회 국회 제1차 법안심사소위원회 회의록, 2014년 4월 16일.(Subcommittee on the Deliberation of Bills in the National Assembly. 2014. "Jae 323hoe Gukhoe Jae1cha Beopansimsasowiwanhoe hoeuirok, April 16, 2014.")
  29. 법제사법위원회. 2014. 제 324회 국회 제1차 법제사법위원회 회의록, 2014년 4월 24일.(Legislation & Judiciary Committee. 2014. "Jae 324hoe Gukhoe Jae1cha Beopjesabeopwiwanhoe hoeuirok, April 24, 2014.")
  30. 사서자격제도 개선을 논하다. 2014. 월드라이브러리. 10월 13일. [online] [cited 2015. 8. 17.] ("Saseojagyeokjedo Gaeseoneul Nonhada." 2014. World Library. October 13. [online] [cited 2015. 8. 17.] )
  31. 사서자격제도, 국가고시화 필요. 2014. 내일신문. 9월 29일. [online] [cited 2015. 8. 17.] ("Saseojagyeokjedo, Gukgagosihwa Pilyo." 2014. Naeil. September 29. [online] [cited 2015. 8. 17.] )
  32. 새 도서정가제 시행에 서점가 "90% 폭탄세일"... 단통법 꼴 날라. 2014. 서울경제. 11월 3일. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] ("Sae Doseojeonggaje Sihange Seojeomga "90% poktanseil" ... Dantongbup Kkol Nalra." 2014. Seoul Economy. November 3. [online] [cited 2015. 6. 25.] )
  33. 송성수, 권기창. 2004. 인터넷내용규제 입법과정에 관한 정책네트워크 분석. 과학기술학연구, 4(1): 83-147.(Song, Sung-Soo and Kwan, Gi-Chang. 2004. "Policy Network Analysis on the Legislation Process of Internet Contents Regulation." Journal of Science & Technology Studies, 4(1): 83-147.)
  34. 양현모, 강동완. 2009. 대북정책 결정과정의 정책네트워크 분석: 개성공단사업 사례를 중심으로. 통일문제연구, 51: 415-458.(Yang, Hyun-Mo and Kang, Dong Wan. 2009. "An Analysis of Policy Network in the Process of Making Policy toward North Korea: Based on the Case of Gaeseong Industrial Complex Project." The Korean Journal of Unification Affairs, 51: 415-458.)
  35. 유진선, 김기영. 2013. '내 생애 첫 도서관' 정책 집행 요인에 대한 연구. 한국비블리아학회지, 24(3): 217-236.(Yoo, Jinsun and Kim, Giyeong. 2013. "A Study of Factors in the Implementation of the 'The First Library in My Life' Policy: Based on Street-Level Bureaucracy Model by Lipsky." Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science, 24(3): 217-236.)
  36. 이덕로. 2012. 기초노령연금정책결정에 관한 사회연결망 분석. 한국정책과학학회보, 16(3): 109-135.(Lee, Deokro. 2012. "A Social Network Analysis on Basic Old-Age Pension Policymaking Process." The Korean Journal of Policy Science, 16(3): 109-135.)
  37. 이선희, 유수현. 2008. 국내외 사례비교를 통한 디지털장서 개발정책 동향 연구. 한국도서관․정보학회지, 39(4): 125-147.(Lee, Seon-Hee and Yoo, Suhyeon. 2008. "A Trend Study on the Digital Collection Development Policy through Case Comparison." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 39(4): 125-147.)
  38. 이승모. 2014. 정책옹호연합모형(ACF)의 적용을 통한 정책변동 분석. 한국정책과학학회보, 18(4): 175-201.(Lee, Seung-Mo. 2014. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework and the Policy Change Analysis: The Case of Electricity Transmission Tower Conflicts in Miryang, Korea." The Korean Journal of Policy Science, 18(4): 175-201.)
  39. 임성은. 2013. 정책네트워크 관점에서 서울시 친환경 무상급식 갈등 분석. 지방행정연구, 27(1): 203-226.(Lim, Sung Eun. 2013. "A Study on the Conflict for Free School Meal Policy in Terms of Policy Network." The Korea Local Administration Review, 27(1): 203-226.)
  40. 장윤금, 노동조, 곽승진. 2008. 국립디지털도서관 정책수립에 관한 문헌 및 사례고찰. 한국도서관․정보학회지, 39(3): 95-117.(Chang, Yun-Keum, Noh, Dong-Jo and Kwak Seung-Jin. 2008. "A Review of Literature and Cases for Developing National Digital Library Policies." Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society, 39(3): 95-117.)
  41. 추윤미, 김기영. 2013. 경기도사이버도서관 설립의 정책형성과정 분석. 정보관리학회지, 30(3): 71-87.(Chu, Yoonmi and Kim, Giyeong. 2013. "An Analysis of the Policy Making Process of Gyeonggido Cyber Library Establishment: Based on the Policy Streams Model of Kingdon." Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 30(3): 71-87.)
  42. 한국대학도서관연합회. 2014. 도서정가제 확대 시행에 따른 대학도서관의 입장. 서울: 한국대학 도서관연합회.(The Korea University & College Library Association. 2014. Doseojeonggaje hwakdae Sihange Ttarrun Daehakdoseokwanui Ipjang. Seoul: The Korea University & College Library Association.)
  43. 한국대학도서관연합회. 2015. 출판문화진흥법 제22조 제 7항의 "경제적 이익" 해석에 대한 의견. 서울: 한국대학도서관연합회.(The Korea University & College Library Association. 2015. Chulpanmunhwajinheungbeop Je 7hangui Iik Haeseoke Daehan Uigyeon. Seoul: The Korea University & College Library Association.)
  44. 한국대학도서관연합회. 한국대학도서관연합회 웹사이트. 서울: 한국대학도서관연합회. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] (The Korea University & College Library Association. The Korea University & College Library Association Website. Seoul: The Korea University & College Library Association. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] )
  45. 한국도서관협회 정관, 문화체육관광부장관인가. (개정 2015. 3. 30)(Korean Library Association Jeonggwan, Munhwacheyukgwangwangbujanggwaninga. (Partially Amended March 30, 2015))
  46. 한국도서관협회. 2013. 제2차 도서관발전종합계획(안) 관련 한국도서관협회 의견제출, 2013 년 10월 22일.(Korean Library Association. 2013. "Jae2cha Doseogwanbaljeonjonghapgyehoek(an) Gwanryeon Hangukdoseogwanhyeophoe Uigyeonjechul, October 22, 2013.")
  47. 한국도서관협회. 2015. 도서관법 전부개정법률안(도종환의원 등 37명) 공동 발의.(Korean Library Association. 2015. "Doseogwan Jeonbugaejeongbeopryulan(Dojonghwanuiwan Deung 37myeong) Gongdong balui.")
  48. 한국도서관협회. 한국도서관협회 웹사이트. 서울: 한국도서관협회. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] (Korean Library Association. Korean Library Association Website. Seoul: Korean Library Association. [online] [cited 2015. 3. 20.] )
  49. Birkland, T. A. 2014. An Introduction to the Policy Process: Theories, Concepts and Models of Public Policy Making. Florence, USA: Routledge.
  50. Case, D. O. 2010. "A Framework for Information Policies with Examples from the United States." Library Philosophy and Practice 2010, 1-10.
  51. Daugbjerg, C. 1998. "Linking Policy Networks and Environmental Policies: Nitrate Policy Making in Denmark and Sweden 1970-1995." Public Administration, 76(2): 275-294.
  52. Dohler, M. 1991. "Policy Networks, Opportunity Structures and Neo-Conservative Reform Strategies in Health Policy." Empirical Evidence and Theoretical Considerations, 235-296.
  53. Kenis, P. and Schneider, V. 1991. "Policy Networks and Policy Analysis: Scrutinizing a New Analytical Toolbox." Policy Networks and Policy Analysis, 25-59.
  54. Kingdon, J. W. and Thurber, J. A. 1984. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Boston: Little, Brown.
  55. Lipsky, M. 1979. Street Level Bureaucracy. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
  56. Liu, Y. Q. and Zhang, J. 2001. "Digital Library Infrastructure: A Case Study on Sharing Information Resources in China." The International Information & Library Review, 33(2-3): 205-220.
  57. Marsh, D. and Rhodes, R. A. W. 1992. Policy Networks in British Government. Wottonunder-Edge, UK: Clarendon Press.
  58. McClure, C. R. and Jaeger, P. T. 2008. "Government Information Policy Research: Importance, Approaches, and Realities." Library & Information Science Research, 30(4): 257-264.
  59. Ripley, R. B. and Franklin, G. A. 1984. Congress, the Bureaucracy, and Public Policy. Bel Air, USA: Dorsey Press.
  60. Sabatier, P. A. 1987. "Knowledge, Policy-Oriented Learning, and Policy Change an Advocacy Coalition Framework." Science Communication, 8(4): 649-692.
  61. Sabatier, P. A. 1988. "An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role of Policy-Oriented Learning Therein." Policy sciences, 21(2-3): 129-168.
  62. Sabatier, P. A. and Jenkins-Smith, H. 1993. Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Framework. Boulder, USA: Westview.
  63. Sabatier, P. A. and Jenkins-Smith, H. C. 1999. "The Advocacy Coalition Framework: An Assessment." Theories of the policy process, 118: 188.
  64. Shin, D. H. 2008. "Next Generation of Information Infrastructure: A Comparative Case Study of Korea Versus the United States of America." Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 59(11): 1785-1800.
  65. Waller, V. and McShane, I. 2008. "Analysing the Challenges for Large Public Libraries in the Twenty-First Century: A Case Study of the State Library of Victoria in Australia." First Monday, 13(12).