Comparison of Pre-Operation Diagnosis of Thyroid Cancer with Fine Needle Aspiration and Core-needle Biopsy: a Meta-analysis

  • Li, Lei (Zhenjiang Key Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Affiliated Hospital of Jiangsu University) ;
  • Chen, Bao-Ding (Zhenjiang Key Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Affiliated Hospital of Jiangsu University) ;
  • Zhu, Hai-Feng (Zhenjiang Key Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Affiliated Hospital of Jiangsu University) ;
  • Wu, Shu (Zhenjiang Key Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Affiliated Hospital of Jiangsu University) ;
  • Wei, Da (Department of General Surgery, Jiangsu Cancer Hospital) ;
  • Zhang, Jian-Quan (Department of Ultrasound Diagnosis, Shanghai Changzheng Hospital) ;
  • Yu, Li (Zhenjiang Key Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology, Affiliated Hospital of Jiangsu University)
  • Published : 2014.09.15


Background: The aim of this meta-analysis was to compare sensitivities and specificities of fine needle aspiration (FNA) and core needle biopsy (CNB) in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer. Materials and Methods: Articles were screened in Medline, the Cochrane Library, EMBASE and Google Scholar, and subsequently included and excluded based on the patient/problem-intervention-comparison-outcome (PICO) principle. Primary outcome was defined in terms of diagnostic values (sensitivity and specificity) of FNA and CNB for thyroid cancer. Secondary outcome was defined as the accuracy of diagnosis. Compiled FNA and CNB results from the final studies selected as appropriate for meta-analysis were compared with cases for which final pathology diagnoses were available. Statistical analyses were performed for FNA and CNB for all of the selected studies together, and for individual studies using the leave-one-out approach. Results: Article selection and screening yielded five studies for meta-analysis, two of which were prospective and the other three retrospective, for a total of 1,264 patients. Pooled diagnostic sensitivities of FNA and CNB methods were 0.68 and 0.83, respectively, with specificities of 0.93 and 0.94. The areas under the summary ROC curves were 0.905 (${\pm}0.030$) for FNA and 0.745 (${\pm}0.095$) for CNB, with no significant difference between the two. No one study had greater influence than any other on the pooled estimates for diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. Conclusions: FNA and CNB do not differ significantly in sensitivity and specificity for diagnosis of thyroid cancer.


Thyroid;cancer;diagnosis;fine needle aspiration;core-needle biopsy;ultrasound-guided


  1. Alexander EK, Marqusee E, Orcutt J, et al (2004). Thyroid nodule shape and prediction of malignancy. Thyroid, 14, 953-8.
  2. Bain G, Bearcroft PW, Berman LH, Grant JW (2000). The use of ultrasound-guided cutting-needle biopsy in paediatric neck masses. Eur Radiol, 10, 512-5.
  3. Baloch ZW, Cibas ES, Clark DP, et al (2008). The national cancer institute thyroid fine needle aspiration state of the science conference: A summation. Cytojournal, 5, 6.
  4. Bongiovanni M, Spitale A, Faquin WC, Mazzucchelli L, Baloch ZW (2012). The bethesda system for reporting thyroid cytopathology: A meta-analysis. Acta Cytol, 56, 333-9.
  5. Bukhari MH, Niazi S, Hanif G, et al (2008). An updated audit of fine needle aspiration cytology procedure of solitary thyroid nodule. Diagn Cytopathol, 36, 104-12.
  6. Cheng P, Chen ED, Zheng HM, He QX, Li Q (2013). Ultrasound score to select subcentimeter-sized thyroid nodules requiring ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration biopsy in eastern China. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev, 14, 4689-92.
  7. Cheung YC, Wan YL, Lui KW, Lee KF (2000). Sonographically guided core-needle biopsy in the diagnosis of superficial lymphadenopathy. J Clin Ultrasound, 28, 283-9.<283::AID-JCU3>3.0.CO;2-T
  8. Cooper DS, Doherty GM, Haugen BR, et al (2009). Revised american thyroid association management guidelines for patients with thyroid nodules and differentiated thyroid cancer. Thyroid, 19, 1167-214.
  9. Davies L, Welch HG (2006). Increasing incidence of thyroid cancer in the united states, 1973-2002. JAMA, 295, 2164-7.
  10. Gharib H, Papini E, Paschke R, et al (2010). American association of clinical endocrinologists, associazione medici endocrinologi, and europeanthyroid association medical guidelines for clinical practice for the diagnosis and management of thyroid nodules. Endocr Pract, 16, 1-43.
  11. Ha EJ, Baek JH, Lee JH, et al (2014). Core needle biopsy can minimise the non-diagnostic results and need for diagnostic surgery in patients with calcified thyroid nodules. Eur Radiol, 24, 1403-9.
  12. Hahn SY, Shin JH, Han BK, Ko EY, Ko ES (2013). Ultrasonography-guided core needle biopsy for the thyroid nodule: Does the procedure hold any benefit for the diagnosis when fine-needle aspiration cytology analysis shows inconclusive results? Br J Radiol, 86, 20130007.
  13. Hakala T, Kholova I, Sand J, Saaristo R, Kellokumpu-Lehtinen P (2013). A core needle biopsy provides more malignancyspecific results than fine-needle aspiration biopsy in thyroid nodules suspicious for malignancy. J Clin Pathol, 66, 1046-50.
  14. Hanley JA, McNeil BJ (1983). A method of comparing the areas under receiver operating characteristic curves derived from the same cases. Radiology, 148, 839-43.
  15. Harvey JN, Parker D, De P, Shrimali RK, Otter M (2005). Sonographically guided core biopsy in the assessment of thyroid nodules. J Clin Ultrasound, 33, 57-62.
  16. Karstrup S, Balslev E, Juul N, Eskildsen PC, Baumbach L (2001). Us-guided fine needle aspiration versus coarse needle biopsy of thyroid nodules. Eur J Ultrasound, 13, 1-5.
  17. Li N, Du XL, Reitzel LR, Xu L, Sturgis EM (2013). Impact of enhanced detection on the increase in thyroid cancer incidence in the united states: Review of incidence trends by socioeconomic status within the surveillance, epidemiology, and end results registry, 1980-2008. Thyroid, 23, 103-10.
  18. Liu Q, Castelli M, Gattuso P, Prinz RA (1995). Simultaneous fine-needle aspiration and core-needle biopsy of thyroid nodules. Am Surg, 61, 628-32.
  19. Mansor M, Okasha H, Esmat S, et al (2012). Role of ultrasound elastography in prediction of malignancy in thyroid nodules. Endocr Res, 37, 67-77.
  20. Morrison SA, Suh H, Hodin RA (2014). The surgical management of thyroid cancer. Rambam Maimonides Med J, 5, 8.
  21. Moses LE, Shapiro D, Littenberg B (1993). Combining independent studies of a diagnostic test into a summary roc curve: Data-analytic approaches and some additional considerations. Stat Med, 12, 1293-316.
  22. Na DG, Kim JH, Sung JY, et al (2012). Core-needle biopsy is more useful than repeat fine-needle aspiration in thyroid nodules read as nondiagnostic or atypia of undetermined significance by the bethesda system for reporting thyroid cytopathology. Thyroid, 22, 468-75.
  23. Nachiappan AC, Metwalli ZA, Hailey BS, et al (2014). The thyroid: Review of imaging features and biopsy techniques with radiologic-pathologic correlation. Radiographics, 34, 276-93.
  24. Novoa E, Gurtler N, Arnoux A, Kraft M (2012). Role of ultrasound-guided core-needle biopsy in the assessment of head and neck lesions: A meta-analysis and systematic review of the literature. Head Neck, 34, 1497-503.
  25. Park KT, Ahn SH, Mo JH, et al (2011). Role of core needle biopsy and ultrasonographic finding in management of indeterminate thyroid nodules. Head Neck, 33, 160-5.
  26. Quinn SF, Nelson HA, Demlow TA (1994). Thyroid biopsies: Fine-needle aspiration biopsy versus spring-activated core biopsy needle in 102 patients. J Vasc Interv Radiol, 5, 619-23.
  27. Renshaw AA, Pinnar N (2007). Comparison of thyroid fineneedle aspiration and core needle biopsy. Am J Clin Pathol, 128, 370-4.
  28. Ridder GJ, Technau-Ihling K, Boedeker CC (2005). Ultrasoundguided cutting needle biopsy in the diagnosis of head and neck masses. Laryngoscope, 115, 376-7.
  29. Rosman AS, Korsten MA (2007). Application of summary receiver operating characteristics (sroc) analysis to diagnostic clinical testing. Adv Med Sci, 52, 76-82.
  30. Screaton NJ, Berman LH, Grant JW (2003). Us-guided coreneedle biopsy of the thyroid gland. Radiology, 226, 827-32.
  31. Sipos JA, Mazzaferri EL (2010). Thyroid cancer epidemiology and prognostic variables. Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol), 22, 395-404.
  32. American Cancer Society (2013). Cancer facts & figures 2013. Available at: Accessed August 21, 2014.
  33. Sung JY, Na DG, Kim KS, et al (2012). Diagnostic accuracy of fine-needle aspiration versus core-needle biopsy for the diagnosis of thyroid malignancy in a clinical cohort. Eur Radiol, 22, 1564-72.
  34. Sutton AJ, Duval SJ, Tweedie RL, Abrams KR, Jones DR (2000). Empirical assessment of effect of publication bias on metaanalyses. BMJ, 320, 1574-7.
  35. Tamsel S, Demirpolat G, Erdogan M, et al (2007). Power doppler us patterns of vascularity and spectral doppler us parameters in predicting malignancy in thyroid nodules. Clin Radiol, 62, 245-51.
  36. Tandon S, Shahab R, Benton JI, et al (2008). Fine-needle aspiration cytology in a regional head and neck cancer center: Comparison with a systematic review and meta-analysis. Head Neck, 30, 1246-52.
  37. Vidal-Casariego A, Lopez-Gonzalez L, Jimenez-Perez A, et al (2012). Accuracy of ultrasound elastography in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer in a low-risk population. Exp Clin Endocrinol Diabetes, 120, 635-8.
  38. Wells GA, Shea B, O'Connell D, et al (2000). The newcastleottawa scale (nos) for assessing the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses. The 3rd symposium on systematic reviews: Beyond the basics. Oxford, England.
  39. Yassa L, Cibas ES, Benson CB, et al (2007). Long-term assessment of a multidisciplinary approach to thyroid nodule diagnostic evaluation. Cancer, 111, 508-16.
  40. Yeon JS, Baek JH, Lim HK, et al (2013). Thyroid nodules with initially nondiagnostic cytologic results: The role of coreneedle biopsy. Radiology, 268, 274-80.
  41. Zamora J, Abraira V, Muriel A, Khan K, Coomarasamy A (2006). Meta-disc: A software for meta-analysis of test accuracy data. BMC Med Res Methodol, 6, 31.

Cited by

  1. Applying Ultrasound-Guided Core Needle Biopsy for Diagnosis of Thyroid Masses vol.34, pp.10, 2015,
  2. The role of core-needle biopsy in the diagnosis of thyroid malignancy in 4580 patients with 4746 thyroid nodules: a systematic review and meta-analysis vol.54, pp.2, 2016,
  3. Comparison of diagnostic yield of core-needle and fine-needle aspiration biopsies of thyroid lesions: Systematic review and meta-analysis vol.27, pp.1, 2017,
  4. Fine-needle aspiration versus core needle biopsy for diagnosis of thyroid malignancy and neoplasm: a matched cohort study vol.27, pp.2, 2017,
  5. Comparison of Consecutive Results from Fine Needle Aspiration and Core Needle Biopsy in Thyroid Nodules vol.28, pp.4, 2017,
  6. Systematic reviews of diagnostic tests in endocrinology: an audit of methods, reporting, and performance vol.57, pp.1, 2017,
  7. Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy for differential diagnosis of thyroid nodules: A systematic review and meta-analysis vol.6, pp.6, 2017,