A Study of Comparing and Analyzing Electric Vehicle Battery Charging System and Replaceable Battery System by Considering Economic Analysis

경제성을 고려한 전기자동차 충전시스템과 배터리 교체형 시스템의 비교분석 연구

  • 김시연 (숭실대학교 전기공학과) ;
  • 황재동 (숭실대학교 전기공학과) ;
  • 임종훈 (숭실대학교 전기공학과) ;
  • 송경빈 (숭실대학교 전기공학과)
  • Received : 2012.03.20
  • Accepted : 2012.07.25
  • Published : 2012.09.01


Electric vehicle usage is currently very low, but it will be increase with development of electric vehicle technology and a good government policy. Moreover in 2020, advanced electric vehicle manufacturing system will give high performance for its price and mass production. Electric vehicle will become widespread in Korea. From an operational and a planned viewpoint, the electric power demand should be considered in relation to diffusion of electric vehicles. This paper presents the impact of the various battery charge systems. A comparison is performed for electric vehicle charging methods such as, normal charging, fast charging, and battery swapping. In addition, economic evaluation for the replaceable battery system and the quick battery charging system is performed through basic information about charging Infrastructure installation cost. The results of the evaluation show that replaceable battery system is more economical and reliable in side of electric power demand than quick battery charging system.


Supported by : 한국에너지 기술평가원(KETEP)


  1. Hyeontaek Jeong, "EV charge a battery all over the country", KEC, CECC, pp.1-2, 2011. 9.
  2. Auto-Times, "Normal charging is advantageous than fast charging for EV charging", 2011. 4.
  3. ME, "Guideline for EV Public Charging Infrastructure Installation in 2011", pp.6-32, 2011. 2.
  4. Honggwan Son, "Construction Direction and Trend for EV Charging Infrastructure", KERI, pp.4-34, 2009.
  5. MLTM, "Report of Vehicle registration condition" MLTM-related statistics, 2011. 11.
  6. Junho Ko, "Supply Plan and Promotion Strategy for EV in Seoul", Seoul Development Institute, pp.7-15, 2011.
  7. Green Growth Institute, "Result of 3 years for Green Growth and further Directions", 2011. 8.
  8. Korea Smart Grid Institute, "Establishment Guideline for EV Charging Infrastructure", MKE, pp.52-58, 2010. 9.
  9. KATRI, "Establishment Guideline for EV Charging Infrastructure", KOTSA, 2009. 12.
  10. KOTSA, "Survey of Vehicle mileage in 2009", Seoul Mileage, pp.93-98, 2010. 12.
  11. Kejun Qian, Chengke Zhou, Malcolm Allan, Yue Yuan, "Modeling of Load Demand Due to EV Battery Charging in Distribution Systems", IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER SYSTEMS, pp.802-810. 2011. 5.
  12. Christopher Madrid, Juan Argueta, Jordan Smith, "1999 NISSAN ALTRA-EV WITH LITHIUM-ION BATTERY", SCE ELECTRIC TRANSPORTATION DIVISION, 1999. 12.
  13. Power System Planning Team, "A Study for Impact of Long-term Electricity Demand by DR in Smart-Grid", KPX, pp.82-114, 2012. 1.
  14. Demand Forecasting Team, "Implications and Impact to Power Supply and Demand by EV Coverage", KPX, pp.2, 2009. 11.
  15. MLTM, "Traffic Survey", Average condition. 2010.
  16. MKE Report Reference, "Electricity Gas rate raises", pp.10, 2010. 7.
  17. Chris S. King, American Energy Institute, "The Economics of Real-Time and Time and Time-of-Use Pricing For Residential Consumers", 2001. 6.
  18. S. Shengnam, Z. Tianshu, P. Manisa and R. Saifur, "Impact of TOU Rates on Distribution Load Shapes in a Smart Grid with PHEV Penetration", IEEE PES, 2010.
  19. MKE, "Fifth Electric Supply and Demand Planning", pp.67, 2010. 12.
  20. Siyeon Kim, Jaedong Hwang, Kyungbin Song, "An Analysis of Effect to the Electrical Demand on Increasing Electric Vehicles", The Korean institute of Electrical Engineers, An Autumn Academic Conference, 2011. 10.
  21. Dongsup Kim, "Demand Management and Stability for Power supply and demand", Elec-Times ISSUE & ISSUE, 2012.
  22. KEPCO, "The Monthly Report on Major Electric Power Statistics", No. 402, pp.66-67, 2012.

Cited by

  1. A Study on the Voltage Sag During the EVs Charging Considering Domestic Data vol.29, pp.1, 2015,
  2. Analysis of Vulnerable Districts for Electronic Vehicle Charging Infrastructure based on Gas Stations vol.20, pp.4, 2014,