A Study on the Relative Weights for the Development of University Library Performance Indicator Model

대학도서관 성과지표 모형 개발을 위한 상대적 가중치 연구

  • Published : 2008.12.30

Abstract

Recently, some universities and university libraries have implemented performance management system as a part of managerial innovation, and they have either implemented or are considering implementing BSC. Thus there are needs to develop performance indicator, which is a tool measuring performance of university libraries, based on BSC, and to assess the developed performance indicator's relative weights to analyze which indicators are essential to fulfill and improve the university library's mission. The performance indicators are also affected by the characteristics and perspectives of the people who develop them during the development process. Therefore, it is necessary to analyze the differences among the professional groups in relative weighting of the performance indicator. The purposes of this study are to derive a university library performance indicator model based on BSC, to analyze the importance of each evaluation factor of the derived performance indicator model, and to analyze the differences among the professional groups in relative weighting of the performance indicator model.

References

  1. 조현연, '대학도서관에서의 BSC 적용에 관한 연구,' 가톨릭대학교 산업경영연구, 제13권, pp.31-57
  2. Macquarie University Library 2005-06 strategic plan. [cited 2007. 12. 10]
  3. 조윤희, '대학도서관의 BSC 적용에 관한 연구,' 한국문헌정보학회지, 제40권, 제1호(2006. 3), p.242
  4. Winnie Chim, 'The Quest for Excellence: One Library's Experience,' Library Management, Vol.28, No.6/7(2007), pp.328-335
  5. 최재황, 곽승진, 김정택, '디지털도서관 서비스의 성과지표 측정 및 적용: ISO/DIS 11620:2007을 중심으로,' 한국문헌정보학회지, 제41권, 제3호(2007. 9), pp.81-102
  6. James Self, 'Metrics and Management: Applying the Results of the Balanced Scorecard,' Performance Measurement and Metrics, Vol.5, No.3(2004), pp.101-105 https://doi.org/10.1108/14678040410570111
  7. Cambridge University Library Strategic Plan 2006/7-2010/11. [cited 2007. 12. 14]
  8. 최동득, 정형철, 정종태, 알기귀운 BSC(서울 KOMIT 출판사, 2006), p.37
  9. 버지니아대학 홈페이지, [cited 2007. 10. 24]
  10. 김정택, 대학도서관 성과지표 모형 개발을 위한 상대적 가중치 연구(박사학위논문, 충남대학교 대학원 문헌정보학과, 2008), pp.70-81
  11. James Self, 'From Values to Metrics: Implementation of the Balanced Scorecard at a University Library,' Performance Measurement and Metrics, Vol.4, No.2 (2003), pp.57-63 https://doi.org/10.1108/14678040310486891
  12. 박기성, 배병한, 조규성, 'AHP를 활용한 R&D 부문의 BSC 관점별 가중치 도출,' 한국경영교육학회지, 제42권(2006), pp.119-137
  13. 인하대학교 정석학술정보관 홈페이지. [인용 2007. 12.14]
  14. 버지니아대학 도서관 홈페이지. [cited 2007. 12. 10]
  15. Library Strategic Planning. [cited 2007. 12. 12]
  16. 인디애나 주립대학 도서관 홈페이지. [cited 2007. 12. 10]
  17. Roswitha Poll, 'Managing Service Quality with the Balanced Scorecard,' Advanced in Library Administration and Organization, Vol.20(2003), pp.213-227
  18. Roswitha Poll, 'Managing Service Quality with the Balanced Scorecard,' Advanced in Library Administration and Organization, Vol.20(2003), pp.214-215
  19. 예비로 선정된 핵심성과지표는 대학도서관의 사명, 관점, 주요성공요인에 이르는 각 단계의 인과관계와 주요성공요인 달성 여부를 고려하여 도서관 성과지표 관련 국내·외 선행연구 및 적용사례를 중심으로 선정하였으며 대학도서관에서 측정 가능하고 계량화할 수 있는 지표로 구성하였다
  20. 조윤희, '대학도서관의 BSC 척용에 관한 연구,' 한국문헌정보학회지, 제40권, 제1호(2006.3), pp.241-262
  21. Oxford University Library Services Vision for 2010. [cited 2007. 12. 12]
  22. University of Maryland Libraries Strategic Plan 2005-2007. [cited 2007. 12. 10]
  23. Klaus Ceynowa, 'Managing Academic Information Provision with the Balanced Scorecard: A Project of the German Research Association,' Performance Measurement and Metrics, Vol.3, No.3 (December 2000), pp.157-164
  24. In Pursuit of Our Strategic Vision 2005-2010. [cited 2007. 12. 12]