Development of Web Credibility Evaluation Model Using AHP

AHP를 이용한 웹 사이트 신뢰성 평가 모델 개발

  • 김영기 (경성대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Published : 2008.12.30

Abstract

This study tired to develop the web credibility evaluation model by calculating weighted values and sensitivities of indicators which presented on preceding researches using Analytic Hierarchy Process. "Expert Choice 2000" was used as the tool for analysing AHP. 25 experts are answered for this questionnaire who are selected by judgement sampling method, one of the non-probability sampling method. Also, sensitivity analyses was performed to graphically see how the alternatives change with respect to the importance of the indicators or sub-indicators. The main results are summarized as followings; i) importance analysis in first level factors: trust-worthiness(0,606), expertness(0.222), safety(0.173), ii) importance analysis in second level factors: trustfulness (0.519), reputation(0.087), usefulness (0.102), timeliness(0,093), competency(0.027), security(0.115), reliability(0,058). iii) some of the importance analysis in third level factors: the site provides comprehensive information that is attributed to a specific source(0.252), the site has articles that list citations and references(0.153), the site contains user opinions and reviews(0.072), etc. iv) sensitivity analyses showed that the importance of the indicators or sub-indicators are slightly changed with respect to the alternatives change.

References

  1. 김영기. '이용자들의 웹 사이트 신뢰성 평가 방법에 관한 연구.' 한국도서관.정보학회지, 제38권 제3호(2007. 9), pp.53-72
  2. 김영기. '지식트러스트 센터 (Knowledge Trust Center) 구축.' 최두진 등, 유비쿼터스 사회의 지식, 참여, 그리고 생활. 한국정보문화진흥원 연구보고서(06-18), 2006. pp.37-53
  3. Comsumer Reports WebWatch. 'Consumer Reports WebWatch Guidelines for Independent Airline Ticket-Booking Sites.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  4. Cornsumer Reports WebWatch. 'Consumer Reports WebWatch Guidelines for Search Engine and Navigation Sites.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  5. UC Berkeley University Library. 'Evaluating Web Pages: Techniques to Apply & Questions to Ask.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  6. New Mexico State University Library. 'The Good, the Bad, & the Ugly.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  7. Widener University. 'Evaluate Web Pages.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  8. Comsumer Reports WebWatch. [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  9. Harris, Robert. 'Evaluating Internet Research Sources.' (Version Date: June 15, 2007) [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  10. Iowa State Univ. Library. 'Evaluating Information on the Web.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  11. University of Oregon Library. 'Critical Evaluation of Information Sources.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  12. Schroeder, Ray. 'Evaluating Online Resources Notebook(meta-site on validating online resources.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  13. Comsumer Reports WebWatch. 'Consumer Reports WebWatch Guidelines for Hotel-Booking Sites.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  14. Expert Choice Korea. Expert Choice. [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  15. Stanford Persuasive Technology Lab and Makovsky & Company(2002). 'Stanford-Makovsky Web Credibility Study - Investigating what makes Web sites credible today.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  16. Comsumer Reports WebWatch. 'Law and Disorder: Paid Listings Complicate Search for Quality Lawyers Online.' [cited 2008. 11. 13]
  17. Fogg, B. J. & H. Tseng. 'The Elements of Computer Credibility.' Proceedings of ACM CHI 99 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. vol.1, pp.80-87. New York: ACM Press, 1999. [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  18. Smith, Alastair. 'Evaluation of information sources(a part of the Information Quality WWW Virtual Library),' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  19. Barker, Joe. 'Evaluating Web Pages: Techniques to Apply & Questions to Ask(UC Berkeley-Teaching Library Internet Workshops).' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  20. Stanford Web Credibility Research. 'Stanford Web Credibility Research.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  21. e-Library, Iowa State University. 'Evaluating Information on the Web.' [cited 2008.11. 14]
  22. 김영기. '웹 사이트의 신뢰성 평가에 영향을 미치는 요인과 각 요인의 중요도에 관한 연구.' 한국문헌정보학회지, 제41권 제4호(2007.12), pp.93-111
  23. The Sheridan Library, Johns Hopkins University. 'Evaluating Information Found on the Internet.' [cited 2008.11. 14]
  24. Phillips, M. Critical Evaluation of Resources [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  25. Self, C. S. 'Credibility.' In M. Salwen and D. Stacks Eds., An Integrated Approach to Communication Theory and Research. Mahway, NJ: Erlbaum, 1996
  26. Standler, Ronald B. 'Evaluating Credibility of Information on the Internet.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]
  27. Olin & Uris Library, Cornel University. 'Critically Analyzing Information Sources.' [cited 2008.11. 13]
  28. Princeton Survey Research Associates. A Matter of Trust - What Users Want From Web Sites. 2002. (accessed 2007. 7. 13)
  29. Bell, Colleen. 'Critical Evaluation of Information Sources.' [cited 2008. 6. 19]