Relationship between TQM Performance and Organizational Culture of Dietitians in Institutional Foodservice

단체급식소 영양사의 종합적 품질경영(TQM) 수행과 조직문화와의 관계 규명에 관한 연구

  • Published : 2007.04.30


This study was designed to investigate the correlation between perceived TQM performance and organizational culture of dietitians. The objective of the study is to help the management of foodservice by providing a direction which will elevate perceived TQM performance of dietitians and presenting plans which will ensure effective dietitians. Questionnaires handed out to 308 dietitians worked in institutional foodservice operation including elementary, middle and high schools, hospitals, business and industries. In terms of TQM importance and performance, the more important dietitians perceived, the higher their performance level rose. Data form the IPA, external and internal customer satisfaction, executive ability, communication system and technology, information technology and application ability, food process, strategy, and leadership were required further improvement by dietitians. Of present organizational culture model, human relations model and open systems model were more likely to be adopted by dietitians in middle and high schools. According to the type of foodservice management, the open systems model was more preferred by dietitians from self-operated operations rather than respondents from contracted operations. Canonical correlation analysis between TQM performance and organizational culture showed canonical correlation to be higher (canonical correlations coefficient: .66). In conclusion, TQM performance-organizational culture showed higher canonical correlation. In the organizational culture, foodservice operation is capable of improving the aims for the rational goal model and the open systems model. The results showed that TQM performance and organizational culture had significant relationship, especially positive organizational culture emphasizing on internal process and rational goal model would have influence on TQM performance of dietitians. Foodservice operation, however, should recognize importance of open and development culture to improve dietitians' TQM performance. To apply open system foodservice organization should encourage dietitian and foodservice employees to challenge and compete for the works, Moreover, organizational effort such as information exchange program and support system should be established.


dietitians;organizational culture;TQM


  1. 전희정, 주나미. 2002. 단체급식관리. 교문사. 서울. pp 14-59
  2. Chung SH. 2001. An empirical study on TQM practices in Korean service industry. J. Society of Korea Industrial and Systems Engineering, 24(69): 75-85
  3. Harrison R. 1972. Understanding your organization's character. Harvard Business Review 50(3): 119-128
  4. Hong WS, Jang ML. 2003. The assessment of dietitian's performance by general characteristics of employees. J. Korean Dietetic Association, 9(4): 297-306
  5. Kim CS. 2005. The study on relationship among patterns of leadership, organization culture and efficiency of sports administrative organization. Korea Sport Research, 16(3): 395-404
  6. Kim I, Hong KP, Kim KS. 2001. Impacts of the organizational type of hospitals and managerial characteristics of TQM on the performance. The Korean J. Local Government Studies, 5(1): 169-194
  7. Kim YC, Park SU. 1998. An empirical study on the relationships between cultural type, strength and organizational performance in Korean firms. J. Korean Academy of Management, 6(2): 195-238
  8. Lee JK, Yoo HJ, Lee YS. 2003. A study on total quality management implementation for 'S' College. J. Korean Society for Quality Management, 31(2): 69-81
  9. Nam EW, Kim WS. 1999. Analysis on organization performance based on hospital culture. Korean J. Hospital Management, 4(2): 242-265
  10. Ok SB, Kim KS. 2002. A Study on the application of TQM for effective organization management to university libraries. J. Korean Library and Information Science Society, 33(1): 258-282
  11. Sathe, V. 1985. Culture and corporate related realities. Richard D. Irwin. New York. pp 22-23
  12. Wallach EJ. 1983. Individuals and organization: the cultural match. Training and Development J., 37: 29-36
  13. Tak KC. 2003. Research on the total quality management of the general hospitals. Korean J. Hospital Management, 8(4): 26-58
  14. Choi SK. 1998. On the application of TQM to libraries. J. Korean Library and Information Science Society, 27: 337-367
  15. Lee EH, Jeong, YH, Kim JS, Song RY, Hwang KY. 2003. Statistical method for health care research, Koonja Publisher, Seoul
  16. 강금식. 2004. 품질경영: TQC.TQM. 박영사. 서울. pp 19-31
  17. Quinn RE, Kimberly JR. 1984. Paradox, planning, and perseverance: guidelines for managerial practice. In Kimberly JR Managing Organizational Transitions. Richard D. Irwin. New York. pp 295-313
  18. 임명준. 2000. 종합적 품질경영 도입의 필요성에 관한 이론적 고찰. 안양과학대학 논문집, 제 23집: 511
  19. Martilla JC, James JC. 1977. Importance-performance analysis. J. Marketing. 41(1): 77-79
  20. Park JS. 2005. The Effect of organizational culture types on job satisfaction and intension of turnover perceived by national hospital employees. Korean J. Hospital Management 10(1): 1-24
  21. Yoo SH, Yang TS, Yang KM. 2006. The effects of organizational communication environment on job satisfaction and commitment: a comparative study on CEO leadership style of service firms. J. Korea Service Management Society, 7(2): 31-56
  22. Chong YK. 1998. Evaluation of TQM performance and organizational management effectiveness for foodservice and clinical nutrition service management in hospital settings. Doctral Dissertation. University of Missouri-Columbia, Columbia: MO
  23. Lee EJ. 2001. (An) Analysis of the knowledge-based environment in hospital dietetic departments for the adoption of knowledge management. Master degree thesis. Dongduk Women's University
  24. Zimmerman J, Shortell SM, Rousseau DM, Duffy J, Gillies RR, Knaus W, Devers K, Wagner D, Draper E, 1993. A prospective multicenter study. Crit Care Med 21: 1443-1451
  25. 이무승, 이복영, 조길복, 김홍제. 2004. 현대 품질경영. 진영사. 서울. pp 79-113
  26. Choi SY, Jung HK. 2000. Effects of ownership types, geographical locations and leadership types of medical service institutions on TQM performance. J. Korean Society for Quality Management, 28(1): 151-174
  27. Kim JK. 2002. A study on effect of total quality management on business performance in Korea manufacturing. KOCOMA, 16: 39-57
  28. Quinn. RE, Mc Grath MR. 1985. The transformation of organizational cultures: a competing values perspective. In Frost PJ, Moore LF, Louis M, Lindberg C, Martin J. Organizational cultures. Sage Publications. California. pp 315-334
  29. Schein EH. 1985. Coming to a new awareness of organizational culture. Sloan Management Review. 30: 3-16
  30. Yang IS, Cha JA, Han GS, Chae IS, Lee JM. 2003. Foodservice Management, Kyomunsa. Seoul. pp 5-61
  31. 박재산 2006. 국립병원 간호조직무화 유형과 직무만족, 이직의사간의 인과관계분석. 보건과 사회과학 19: 97-118
  32. Ernest RC. 1985. Corporate culture and effective planning. Personnel Administrator, March: 49-60
  33. Yu HJ. 2003. A comparative study on total quality management education between manufacturing and service companies in Korea. J. Korean Society for Quality Management, 31(4): 55-63
  34. 강병서. 2005. SPSS를 활용한 다변량 통계학. 한경사. 서울. pp 353
  35. Alvarez RJ. 1994. Management total quality in food service. Food Technol, 48(9): 140
  36. Jones GR. 1983. Transaction costs. property rights and organizational culture: an exchange perspective. Administrative Science Quarterly, 28: 454-467
  37. Yoo HJ. 2001. A conformance rating model for the organizational culture to TQM strategy and tools. J. Korean Society for Quality Management, 29(2): 29-36
  38. Park SE, Han SJ. 2001. A study on the relationships between cultural profiles and performances in hospital organizations : an empirical test of competing values model on the Korean hospital organizations. Korean J. Hospital Management, 6(2): 86-114
  39. Lee HY. 2002. Impact of organizational culture on total quality management strategy in family restaurants. Doctoral dissertation. Yonsei University
  40. Kwak DK, Ryu ES, Lee HS, Hong WS, Jang HJ. 2001. Foodservice Management. Sinkwang Publishing Co. Seoul. pp 17-48
  41. Pettigre AM. 1979. On studying organizational culture. Administrative Science Quarterly, 24: 574
  42. Kim JH. 2003. A Study on the effects of rewards factors on performance of total quality management. J. Korean Society for Quality Management, 31(4): 64-80